[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: question

On Thu, 11 Apr 1996, Niels Peter Lemche wrote:

> David,
> If you want to look for the origins of sectarianism, why not have a 
> look on Isa 4? 

Interesting suggestion.

> The question is whether you are looking for sectarianism inside a 
> Jewish society of say the 3rd century, or at a society which is 
> defining itself in a way to be likened to sectarianism - inside a 
> more comprehensivive world.

Are these mutually exclusive alternatives?  In the paper I mentioned I 
also raised the possibility that the place of the priests vis a vis the 
Hellenistic world could also be a factor in the priestly origin of 
apocalypticism.  Here Daniel is of some interest since the initial cycle 
of stories seems to be pre-Maccabean and to deal with the situation of 
Jewish civil servants in the service of an alien king.  

I think that the internal and external issues are interactive.  One of 
the major factors internally seems to be the struggle over adoption of 
Hellenistic culture, which comes to a head with Antiochus.  Likewise, the 
emergence of Judean society as a relatively insulated society on the 
periphery of the Hellenistic world is likely to stimulate factionalism 
within with conflict over purity issues, including marriage (I've been 
re-reading Mary Douglas' Natural Symbols in an effort to come to some 
understanding of this issue).

In the meantime, identification and classification of relevant literature 
seems to me to be of primary importance (Michael's original question).

David Suter
Saint Martin's College