[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
orion OSSENES: WHICH VOLUME FOR EPIPHANIUS?
Dear Russell Gmirkin,
I am absolutely fascinated with your references to Epiphanius (and to the
I would very much appreciate the bibliographical data (Title, Editor,
Year, ISBN) for the volume or volumes you are using. I would like to
delve into this material more thoroughly and think your concise email
would be a great roadmap for doing so.
On Fri, 22 Jan 1999 01:49:53 EST RGmyrken@aol.com writes:
> First, let me apologize for my inaccurate statement that you
>claimed that >"Philo was a Stoic." I wrote my last posting on my
laptop, away from
>my >office and documents I should have reviewed before sending my email.
>You were >right to take me to task for misrepresenting you on that
> Since you have seen fit to respond mainly regarding the Ossenes in
>Epiphanius, I will confine my reply to same. > First, the Ossenes
were clearly of Jewish origin. Epiphanius >indicates >they originated in
pre-Christian times (19.5.6). As you pointed out >from >19.15.1, they
kept "the Jewish life in Sabbath observance,
>circumcision, and >the keeping of the law." However, they are also
>"forbidding the >books <of Moses> like the Nasaraeans" (19.15.1,
continuing the quote; >the >Nasaraeans were Jews who kept all Jewish
customs but for sacrifices,
>but >claimed that Moses did not author the Pentateuch [18.1.4]), and
>"accepted >other writings in addition to the law, though they rejected
>the >prophets who came afterwards" (Abstract 15.18, which, though
>not by >Epiphanius, nevertheless contains comparable information).
>according >to Epiphanius they had succumbed to the heresy of the
>(Sampseans). >This is immediately relevant to your equation of Essene
with "doers of >the >law." Even if the Ossenes had once observed Jewish
>they have >retained the name Ossene after rejecting the Torah and
> Your comment that the Ossenes "lived near the Dead Sea" is quite
>misleading. Epiphanius says that they lived "in Nabatea and Iturea,
>Moab and >the country around Areopolis, the regions lying *over and
>the >Holy Scripture calls the ^—salt valley^“; this is what is called the
>Dead Sea" >(19.1.2). At 53.1.1. this same region (where the Sampseans
>lived) is >described as "the country called Perea, on the *far side* of
>called >the Salt or Dead Sea, <and> in Moab near the Torrent Arnon and
>in >Iturea and Nabatea." Perea was of course an ancient equivalent of
>"Transjordan", and the "salt valley" is the Arabah. Moab and Arnon are
>of course beyond but adjacent to the Dead Sea. Epiphanius could not be
>clear. >All the locations Epiphanius lists are in Transjordan, east of
>Dead Sea, >not west where the Essenes dwelt (per Pliny).
> Responding to George X. Brook^“s query, it is Epiphanius who
>portrays the >Essenes as an extinct branch of the Samaritans. (14.2.1
>mistakenly >traces the Sadducees to the Samaritans.) Epiphanius is
>drawing on >Josephus or any other known literary source. Yet he
>preserved the >name Essene here. This is a fact that calls for
>simplest one >being that Essene is the proper form of the name.
> Russell Gmirkin
For private reply, e-mail to George Brooks <email@example.com>
To unsubscribe from Orion, e-mail to firstname.lastname@example.org with
the message: "unsubscribe Orion." For more information on the Orion Center
or for Orion archives, visit our web site http://orion.mscc.huji.ac.il.