[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: orion Spaceless "BYTYHWH" inscription

 Dear Niels Peter, who wrote:

 >Date of inscription, please!

Whoops, sorry I forgot to mention that the BAR article says the inscription
is believed to date  from somewhere between 9th and 7th centuries BCE.

NPL further wrote:

>However, which bytyhwh does the inscription speak of? The one in
>Jerusalem or another one. If we speak of so-called first temple
>period, there were probable scores of temples of YHWH - probably also
>later ... and is it a surprise? After all we have scores if not
>hundred of Yahwistic names from the Iron Age.

Your hypothesis of the existence of umpteen Temples of YHWH in the first
Temple period is interesting.  I am looking  forward to your evidence
(literary, archaeological, or what?) to support this notion.   My mind is
open to the theoretical possibility -- but I  hope you will not simply fall
back on an argument that "absence of evidence"  is not "evidence of

That would be only marginally more acceptable than your suggestion in a
recent BAR debate that the likeliest explanation for the Tel Dan
inscription and the Ekron Philistine inscription was that they were fakes
or forgeries.  (You might want to take a look at the latest BAR, which
indicates that many scholars have taken its editor to task for printing
that innuendo without comment -- and also includes assorted refutations