[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: Who killed Goliath--David or Elhanan???
>>Niels Peter and Moshe,
>>Actually Rashi got it from Targum Jonatan.
>Rashi always draws from other sources. In the Torah it is primarily from a
>Midrash called 'Midrash Aggadah'.
> /\ /\
> ____/_ \____ ____/_ \____
> \ ___\ \ / Moshe Shulman \ ___\ \ /
> \/ / \/ / \/ / \/ /
> / /\__/_/\ email@example.com / /\__/_/\
> /__\ \_____\ /__\ \_____\
> \ / \ /
> \/ \/
While I am not an expert in medieval Judaism, my impression was that
Midrash Aggadah would have been written a bit late for Rashi. Or have I
got my dates muddled?
Paul V. M. Flesher
University of Wyoming
Laramie, WY 82071-3353